Quantcast The Daily Campus
College Media Network

The Daily Campus

American Bashing of Israel Must Cease

Abstract:
Israel is a small nation with big enemies. Established as a Jewish state in 1948, Israel has been fighting for its survival since its inception. Less than a week after declaring independence, Israel was invaded by its Arab neighbors in an attempt to destroy the sovereign country....

  • Displaying 1 - 8 of 8

Rick

posted 10/02/07 @ 10:33 AM EST

Why is it that Americans can criticize every other nation in the world, including our own ... but hands off Israel? If society has been misled or the media have been dishonest, then set us straight. But do it with hard facts, not mere pejorative labels and counter-assertions.

It's good that Israeli intelligence stopped a potential terrorist attack in Tel Aviv a week ago. But that sounds like an internal matter. How does that make us allied in the war on terror?

I look at statistics on military deaths in Iraq since the start of the Iraq war. 3,803 Americans so far, 297 from 18 allied countries. Israel is not one of those countries. Personally, I think Israel should be sending US money to fight the war on terror, since Israel is the principal beneficiary of it.

R

posted 10/02/07 @ 1:21 PM EST

Originally posted by

Rick

Why is it that Americans can criticize every other nation in the world, including our own ... but hands off Israel? If society has been misled or the media have been dishonest, then set us straight. But do it with hard facts, not mere pejorative labels and counter-assertions.

It's good that Israeli intelligence stopped a potential terrorist attack in Tel Aviv a week ago. But that sounds like an internal matter. How does that make us allied in the war on terror?

I look at statistics on military deaths in Iraq since the start of the Iraq war. 3,803 Americans so far, 297 from 18 allied countries. Israel is not one of those countries. Personally, I think Israel should be sending US money to fight the war on terror, since Israel is the principal beneficiary of it.


The article isn't condemning criticism of Israel. It's condemning biased media coverage of the conflict occurring in that area. It can be argued that the media is selectively biased, but the fact of the matter is that too many liberal news sources (and I consider myself a liberal, by the way) publish poorly researched articles about the "crimes" Israel allegedly commits against 'Palestinian' innocents.

Jill

posted 10/02/07 @ 10:34 AM EST

well written thoughtful article

Nizzle

posted 10/02/07 @ 11:11 PM EST

I agree

Saleh

posted 10/03/07 @ 1:55 AM EST

This article is full of fallacies...

1) It is so hypocritical that you are so proud that Israeli newspapers have the freedom to criticize the Israeli government (and its violations of international and humanitarian laws), yet you are so angry when American media and newspapers occasionally do the same thing!

2) It is flat-out dishonest to ignore the very crucial question of why those angry neighbors of Israel are angry in the first place. You attempt to deceive the readers by pairing phrases like "anti-Israel" and "antisemitism" together, and leave the reader to conclude that the Arabs were angry simply because they hated the Jews! You are either ignorant or intentionally ignoring the real reasons why the Arabs had to fight Israel...

It is a fact that there has been no conflicts between the Jews and the Arabs for over 1300 years, and that in most cases Jews were treated very well in Muslim-ruled states, until the conflict over Palestine broke out last century. The conflict was a consequence of the Zionists' plan of a mass Jewish migration from allover the world, especially from Eastern Europe and Russia, to flood the land of Palestine. Jews moved from the situation where they composed no more than 8% of the Palestinian population at the beginning of the 20th century, to over 30% in 1948. Moreover, those Jewish immigrants while under the British occupation of Palestine organized themselves in criminal gangs and exploited the fact that the local population resisted the British occupation and virtually sided with the occupier gaining the political, financial and military support of the British, (by the way, Israel continues to play the exact same role today, but today they are exploiting the United States instead)...Once the British occupation left Palestine in 1948, the Zionists declared the establishment of a "Jewish" state in Palestine. No wonder then why the angry neighbors had to fight against the "Jewish" state... NOT because it is Jewish, but because it was established on someone else's property...

I truly feel sympathy with the Jews who were oppressed in Europe, and I would support their efforts to restore their dignity and welfare. But is it fair that the solution be to oppress yet another people!!! If those Jews who were oppressed possess no hearts to sympathize with their own victims (the Palestinians), then it is just a matter of time before history repeats itself.

R

posted 10/03/07 @ 1:18 PM EST

Originally posted by

Saleh



2) It is flat-out dishonest to ignore the very crucial question of why those angry neighbors of Israel are angry in the first place. You attempt to deceive the readers by pairing phrases like "anti-Israel" and "antisemitism" together, and leave the reader to conclude that the Arabs were angry simply because they hated the Jews! You are either ignorant or intentionally ignoring the real reasons why the Arabs had to fight Israel...

It is a fact that there has been no conflicts between the Jews and the Arabs for over 1300 years, and that in most cases Jews were treated very well in Muslim-ruled states, until the conflict over Palestine broke out last century. The conflict was a consequence of the Zionists' plan of a mass Jewish migration from allover the world, especially from Eastern Europe and Russia, to flood the land of Palestine. Jews moved from the situation where they composed no more than 8% of the Palestinian population at the beginning of the 20th century, to over 30% in 1948. Moreover, those Jewish immigrants while under the British occupation of Palestine organized themselves in criminal gangs and exploited the fact that the local population resisted the British occupation and virtually sided with the occupier gaining the political, financial and military support of the British, (by the way, Israel continues to play the exact same role today, but today they are exploiting the United States instead)...Once the British occupation left Palestine in 1948, the Zionists declared the establishment of a "Jewish" state in Palestine. No wonder then why the angry neighbors had to fight against the "Jewish" state... NOT because it is Jewish, but because it was established on someone else's property...


Yes, it certainly was established on someone else's property. THE BRITISH GOVERNMENT'S PROPERTY. I sympathize with the displaced groups, but the fact of the matter is that the 'Palestinians' did not own the land they were living on, and the rightful owners (THE BRITISH)displaced them. Not the Jews.

Death in all conflict is senseless, whether Jewish Israeli or Arab Israeli, but the 'blame game' is getting old, especially when played incorrectly.

Saleh

posted 10/05/07 @ 7:20 AM EST

Claiming that the British government owned the land of Palestine is like saying that a robber owns the money he robs from a bank...The rightful owners of the land are the Palesinians who lived there forever, not the british who occupied it a hundred years ago or the Jews who migrated there recently.

Jonathan

posted 10/13/07 @ 11:53 PM EST

Well-written article. People just don't understand that the Israeli government is TRYING to make peace. They are TRYING to give away the West Bank. It's just that no responsible government will take it.
  • Displaying 1 - 8 of 8

Post Your Comment

  • NOTE: Email address will not be published

Type your comment below (html not allowed)

  I understand posting spam or other comments that are unrelated to this article will cause my comment to be flagged for deletion and possibly cause my IP address to be permanently banned from this server.

Advertisement

Advertisements

Poll

Do you feel safe on campus?
Submit Vote

View Results

Advertisement